Tuesday, May 27, 2025

Americana Flag Sweater: Ralph Lauren vs. Tuckernuck

Ralph Lauren (left)// Tuckernuck (right, also love this one!)

I love a good flag sweater. They are timeless and great for kids, men, grandparents... literally anyone and everyone. It's a staple I wear SO much, and I also wear it year-round. I'm updating this post I wrote in last year because I found a few more flag sweaters to add into the mix in case you are shopping for one, considering 4th of July is around the corner, so scroll to the bottom to see the updates! 

I have both the Tuckernuck flag sweater and the Ralph Lauren flag sweater. Many other brands also offer flag sweaters, but I will focus on these two since I own them both! 

Cost:
Tuckernuck: $198 (use code YOUROCK or YOURULE)
Ralph Lauren: $398

Materials:
Tuckernuck: 100% cotton
Ralph Lauren: 100% cotton

Sizing:
Tuckernuck: It's true to size, but you could size down for a closer fit. It's roomy/boyfriend-style, but I love that.
Ralph Lauren: True to size, a slimmer, closer fit vs. Tuckernuck. 

Fit: 
Tuckernuck: Both the neckline and the sleeve hems are rolled, which is nice and adds to the sweater's casual vibe. The neckline is between a crew and a mock neck. The length is a bit longer and more a-line than the Ralph Lauren sweater. 

Ralph Lauren: This is a true, classic crewneck sweater that hits right at the hip and has a flattering, slimmer fit. 

My thoughts:
Tuckernuck: For being about $150 less, I prefer the Tuckernuck version, so if you are considering one or the other, the Tuckernuck is less costly but just as nice as the Ralph Lauren. If you prefer a more classic crewneck style, Tuckernuck makes a version for $198, which is still $100 less than the Ralph Lauren version. 

Ralph Lauren: I love this Ralph Lauren sweater. I've had it for over 10 years, and it has held up perfectly. It is high quality and classic. I don't love the RL logo on the sweater; it's unnecessary. My husband has this one in navy, and it looks so handsome on him. 

The stars are embroidered on both, and nothing is printed on either.  

Bottom Line:
You can't go wrong with either, but when it comes down to price, you can save $150 and go with the Tuckernuck option, and I think you'd be just as happy! 

Scroll below to see many outfits of how I have styled both sweaters over the years and seasons. 













My husband has the men's Ralph Lauren version in Navy blue.

UPDATE:

Over the last few months, many new options worth sharing have popped up at all different price points! 





This sweater is a great option for under $50. It's 100% cotton, and it fits true to size. The quality is great. The only thing that's pretty different from the Tuckernuck and RL options is that the stars are not stitched. I do think the stars being stitched on gives it a nicer look, but at under $50, it's still a beautiful sweater!

The sweater sells out but pops back in stock, so if you see it sold out, it's worth keeping an eye on. There is also an option via Target. It's a cotton/poly blend, so choose the ON option before considering the Target option!

Are you following me on the LikeToKnowIt app?! You can shop all of my outfits, favorite finds, and more in the app. I am constantly updating it with the latest! You can also access all of my posts, here, if you don't use LTK! You can also find me on ShopMy, another shopping platform! 

This content may contain affiliate links; when you click the link and make a purchase, I may receive a commission (at no cost to you). 

2 comments:

hollygolightly said...

This sweater is absolutely timeless. I love that, despite changes in trends, this is a perennial and you can’t go wrong (that’s to say all ages and people can pull this off). What a good idea for a blog article!

Emily VanderZwalm said...

This is marvelous! Your diligence is much appreciate!

 

© Summer Wind Blog 2017 / site design by kiki and co. / disclosure